RSS Feed

Thinking & Writing in Third Person

Posted on
Thinking & Writing in Third Person

Recently my fiancé and I reread a passage in Huston Smith’s The World’s Religions that we both really like. It’s from the chapter on Hinduism, in the section on “The Way to God through Knowledge.” (I have actually written about this passage before.)

Hindus believe that a person is more than his or her body and more than his or her “surface” personality; on a deeper level everyone posses an “infinite Self that underlies one’s transient, finite self” (31). The task in life, they say, is to distinguish between the two: “[The yogi] needs to drive a wedge between her skin-encapsulated ego and her [infinite center].”

One way to do this is to practice thinking of oneself in the third person, for example:

Instead of “I am walking down the street,” she thinks, “There goes Sybil walking down Fifth Avenue,” and tries to reinforce the assertion by visualizing herself from a distance…  Thinking of oneself in the third person does two things simultaneously. It drives a wedge between one’s self-identification and one’s surface self, and at the same time forces this self-identification to deeper level until, at last, through a knowledge identical with being, one becomes in full what one always was at heart (Smith 31-32).

Eva at Yogaville.

Eva at Yogaville in Virginia with the LOTUS shrine in the background.

 

Most of us, however, think in first person. And writing in first person is the natural point of view for many writers. First person is intimate and confessional — it’s the way we tell stories in real life. But its ease is deceptive. When writing in first person, you run the risk of “telling” too much, of spending too much time inside the narrator’s head. Besides, your story may not call for an intimate and confessional tone. Or you may need the reader to know information your first person narrator wouldn’t know or understand.

A few years ago, I wrote a middle-grade fantasy novel, and this past summer I obtained an agent for it. Initially I wrote the novel in first person, present tense. After a while, I realized the present tense wasn’t working with its fable-like tone, so I rewrote it in past tense. But I kept getting comments from my agent and editor about the narrator. That she seemed distant. That her personality wasn’t coming through on the page. Finally I realized it was because this fable-like adventure story didn’t need a first person narrator. I rewrote it in third person, and now I think it works much better.

You know what else forces you to think about yourself objectively -- self portrai

You know what else forces you to think about yourself objectively — self portraits.

 

Back in the summer, my agent asked if I had any other middle-grade fantasy novels, and I told him no.

“Hmm, it sure would be great if you could start working on another one,” he said.  Not a sequel, necessarily, but something similar to the book he was going to shop around. It would be easier to sell my novel if there was the promise of another one coming down the pipeline.

I’ve always been very good at taking direction, so I got to work and wrote another fable-like middle-grade novel. And guess what I wrote it in… first person. And guess what the women in my writing group said? That despite the first person POV, they didn’t feel close enough to the narrator — that there was something not-quite-right about her voice.

Duh. It’s because this book belongs in third person, too. I just finished making the switcheroo, and already I think it works a hundred times better.

I wonder if this is going to continue to be my process: write a book in my go-to first person voice and then (probably) change it to third person.  Hey, whatever works, right?

Oops, I did it again!

Oops, I did it again!

 

I always thought that writing in first person was the best way to get to know a character, but now, after switching two books from first to third, I think I might be wrong. Third person gives you a chance to see your characters from a distance that can be enlightening. With third person, you can really watch your characters, notice their actions and behaviors, begin to understand them…perhaps better than they understand themselves.

When I tell people about having to rewrite two novels they groan and say “that sucks.” But it didn’t suck at all. It let me see the stories in a different light. Ironically, the distance helped me delve deeper into the main characters’ psyches, so that they could become what they always were at heart.

 

Further Reading:  

7 Dangers of First Person Narrators

Six Limitations of the First Person Narrator

Five Advantages of Third Person Omniscient POV

Is Your First-Person Narrator Overpowering Your Story?

 

Advertisements

About evalangston

Eva Langston is a writer, among other things.

2 responses »

  1. It really is surprising how much more you learn when you switch from first person to third person… but then maybe if we switch from third person to first we learn a whole lot more, too. I do like my tendency toward third these days, though. Sometimes I feel claustrophobic in first person now.

    Thanks for offering this to us–a good read!

    Reply
  2. I liked the third person and used it even in poetry, great post, love it, came through Huston Smith tag.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: